The Value of Niacin (vitamin B3) in Supporting Schizophrenia

WHAT IS SCHIZOPHRENIA?

In the UK, at any one time about 220,000 people are being treated for schizophrenia by the NHS. Whilst it is a less common mental health condition, statistics show that there is a higher risk associated to suicide and greater vulnerability to physical conditions like diabetes, perhaps due to medications such as antipsychotics. Due to this, statistics show that people with schizophrenia die on average 10 – 20 years earlier than the general population.

Schizophrenia is characterised by two different groups of symptoms, which are classified as ‘positive’ and ‘negative’. Positive symptoms are the changes in behaviour and thoughts described as hallucinations (hearing voices or seeing things that others don’t), delusions and paranoia. The negative symptoms include feeling disconnected from other people, less interested in life, emotionless and sometimes disorganised thought and speech. 

The exact cause of schizophrenia is still misunderstood, with various theories pointing to a number of different biochemical imbalances, including genetic mutations that can provide the foundations for the disorder to develop. 

WHAT CAUSES SCHIZOPHRENIA?

One of the most popular theories on the cause of schizophrenia, which is widely accepted by the scientific and medical community, is the dopamine excess hypothesis, that is, too much dopamine in the brain that can cause the positive symptoms of psychosis to occur. Antipsychotics are the most commonly prescribed medications to target positive symptoms and prevent psychosis. Whilst they have proven to be critical in targeting excessive dopamine signalling in the brain, antipsychotics can also lead to health complications such as metabolic syndrome, the worsening of negative symptoms and nutrient depletion, which overall can be detrimental to a patients’ health over a long period of time. Studies show that common antipsychotics such as clozapine can lead to the depletion of selenium and l-tryptophan. Both nutrients are incredibly important to maintain health - selenium is an essential mineral, which is a precursor to glutathione, the body’s most important antioxidant and l-tryptophan is an amino acid precursor to serotonin, which is known to prevent depression and enhance mental wellbeing.

ALTERNATIVE THEORIES

Another key theory, founded by the late Dr Abraham Hoffer and his colleagues Humphrey Osmand and John Smythies in 1954, is the adrenochrome theory. This theory initially came about after studying the symptoms caused by hallucinogenic drugs such as LSD, mescaline and amphetamines. The researchers noted these symptoms were similar to those experienced by schizophrenics including euphoria, derealisation and hallucinations, accompanied by paranoia and depression. They then discovered that the chemical structure of adrenaline was also similar to mescaline and LSD, which lead them into researching the effect of adrenochromes on the brain. 

WHAT ARE ADRENOCHROMES? 

Adrenochromes are metabolites of adrenaline, the hormone and neurotransmitter that is responsible for our body’s ‘fight or flight’ response. It is believed that derivatives of adrenaline and other similar compounds such as dopaminochrome and noradrenochrome, can be neurotoxic in large quantities and cause mood-altering effects. 

The adrenochrome theory is further supported by studies that have shown how in those with schizophrenia, the enzyme glutathione s-transferase, (responsible for clearing the brain from neurotoxic compounds such as adrenochrome, dopaminochrome and noradrenochrome) is commonly defective, thus leading to an accumulation of these substances in the brain. 

WHAT IS NIACIN’S (B3) ROLE IN PREVENTING SYMPTOMS OF SCHIZOPHRENIA? 

Abraham Hoffer and his team theorised that in order to reduce the production of adrenochromes, a methyl acceptor such as B3 would be needed. Methyl acceptor is the name for nutrients, mainly in the B vitamin family, which each play an important role in a biochemical process known as methylation. This process is needed for a variety of biochemical reactions, such as building and breaking down neurotransmitters, supporting liver detox pathways and DNA repair, to name a few.  

Upon studying the pathway for adrenaline production in the brain and the cofactor nutrients supporting and inhibiting this pathway, Hoffer deduced that by giving large doses of vitamin B3, which is a methyl acceptor, this would effectively prevent the conversion of noradrenaline to adrenaline, and by limiting the amount of adrenaline, this would then prevent the build up of adrenochromes. 

In addition, B3 is also a precursor to nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD), a compound that is involved in redox reactions, which prevents oxidative stress caused by free radicals. These are unstable molecules that scavenge electrons from other molecules, causing a chain reaction that can eventually damage tissues in the body. NAD prevents the oxidation of adrenaline, which is what turns adrenaline into adrenochromes, therefore preventing the production of these neurotoxins that over time can damage the brain.

HOW RELIABLE IS THE ADRENOCHROME THEORY? 

Between the years 1953 to 1960, Hoffer researched and studied patients with schizophrenia, publishing a total of six double-blindclinical trials. In one study, conducted in 1962, 82 patients (39 in the niacin group and 43 in the placebo group) were involved and were given niacin throughout a period of 33 days. The results showed that 79.5% in the niacin group improved significantly in comparison to the placebo group, which was 41.9%. 

Despite the positive results that these 6 studies showed, other studies on patients with chronic schizophrenia who had been suffering for longer periods of time, demonstrated how B3 was not as effective. In one particular study using 32 patients, after two years of niacin use no positive effect was registered.

A recent meta-analysis of the effects of vitamins and minerals on schizophrenia identified 18 clinical trials in which 832 patients on antipsychotics were involved. The analysis found that high dose B vitamins (including B3, B6 B9 and B12) were consistently effective for reducing psychiatric symptoms, in comparison to studies where low dose B vitamins were used. 

HOW SAFE IS NIACIN TREATMENT? 

Doses of niacin for schizophrenia are recommended between 3,000mg - 18,000mg a day in order to have a substantial effect. It should be noted, however, that niacin treatment must be monitored by a qualified health professional or doctor and should not be self-prescribed. Due to niacin’s side-effects, which are characterised by hot flushes and red skin rashes, many may choose to opt for a ‘no-flush’ version of the niacin supplement. However, studies have shown the risk of liver toxicity with high doses of the timed release and no-flush version of niacin, so this should be avoided. 

In addition, niacin on its own is rarely enough to address symptoms of schizophrenia. Each person is unique, and therefore there are many other factors which should be taken into consideration, such as digestion and inflammation.